There was one hilarious commercial some time back from an automobile
company which played on the Indian psyche of putting overwhelming
emphasis on the mileage over everything else. “Kitna deti hai?”, was
the question that the curious onlooker had asked of an incredulous
protagonist – one was explaining about Rockets, another a luxury Yatch
& yet another about a new generation battle tank!
But, I was not surprised; for I face the same questions from those I
deal with.
Focus on the basics : What are we trying to achieve in life? Are we
trying to get maximum returns to the exclusion of everything else? If
so, will it solve all the problems?
Most people focus on returns and chase products that offer the best
returns at any point. There is indeed an insistent belief that high
returns are something that we need to constantly strive for, to get
ahead in life. Hence, we tend to pick up the products which are “hot”
or trending, at any given point.
The predominant majority get it wrong as they join the bandwagon pretty
late – whether it is a stock market rally or a gold / real estate surge.
In doing so, they typically tend to get in when the rally is well
underway. In such a situation, they tend to purchase at inflated prices
which will cap their upsides or worse still, set them up for potential
downsides when the rally blows over.
Let me take an example. Suppose, Ramesh has bought real estate in 2012
when the markets were doing reasonably well. However, the markets have
turned turtle and are offering low to negative returns since. If Ramesh
has bought property, just to ride the wave, a lot of things would have
gone horribly wrong.
Firstly, the objective of fantastic return has not been met. Secondly,
Ramesh has taken some loans which he is servicing and paying a high
interest for an asset, which is not appreciating. He has not
considered any other parameter while investing – like liquidity,
concentration risk, risk inherent in this asset, tenure, returns etc.
This has been a blind investment into what is essentially an illiquid
product. Ramesh wants to sell & exit – but cannot, as there are no
buyers! He is now badly stuck. Many would be able to identify with
this.
People get into such transactions based on early successes. They tend to
feel invincible, if the first few transactions go well. Bets go up
steadily with each transaction – which is where the problem is.
Eventually when the cycle turns, they are left holding their lemons. A
string of successes in the beginning is, however, a wrong teacher!
People advertise their successes while quietly burying their failures in
investment. When some talk passionately about their successes, there
are many who get taken in – and the cycle of people trooping in to feed a
frenzy, gets underway.
While moving from product to product chasing returns, we fail to
consider important parameters which are equally important – like
liquidity, risk-reward, suitability, tenure etc. Such dalliances hardly
help in progressing towards smooth achievement of the goals.
Focus on goals : What is important in life is to achieve the
significant goals one may have. In fact, achieving our goals in the
time frames that we want is what is of paramount importance.
The typical high priority goals are – retirement, children’s education,
acquiring a home etc. Each goal will have a certain time horizon.
Investments will have to be done so that we may be able to meet the
goals. Hence, the investment should be such that it is consistent with
the need to achieve the goal.
For instance, if Ramesh wants to plan for child’s education, it might be
a decade away. For this goal, his investments can be in comparatively
aggressive assets like equities. In this case, near term liquidity is
not a concern area, tenure of the investment can be long & regular
income is not necessary.
Once we decide on the instrument which has the potential for good
returns, we can stay invested and not liquidate it to chase the next
rainbow which appears on the horizon. Many of the assets have their
cycles & those who stay invested for long, get to weather the cycles
better; also, with longer tenure, the inherent risk reduces & the
return potential improves. Market timing becomes less and less
important, if the tenure is long.
Strategic & Tactical asset allocation : Normally, client’s assets
are allocated based on their goals, how long the client has till
retirement, their risk tolerance levels & other considerations like
liquidity, risk-reward of the asset, requirement of regular returns
& their frequency etc.
Once the assets have been allocated as per such considerations, it
should be allowed to work. For that, the assets should be allowed to
remain invested for long to show desired results. That is the strategic
asset allocation.
Based on the movements in the markets & based on opportunistic
considerations, one may want to bring in some new assets which are doing
well then & make certain changes to the portfolio. But these
changes should be such that they tinker around the edges & not
change the core allocation. This is a tactical asset allocation to
potentially take advantage of the unfolding opportunities. A change in
the portfolio constitution of 10-15% can be fine when it comes to
tactical allocation. If it goes beyond that, it will change the
strategic asset allocation that has been suggested, which is not
desirable.
In summary : Goal achievement is what is really important. Hence, it
is important to keep the focus on the life goals, more than what
investment returns one gets at any point. One should invest in a
disciplined manner following the strategic asset allocation suggestions,
which is what ensures goal achievement. It is not necessary to get all
excited about assets which are doing well at some intermediate point;
it’s more important to stay focused on the goal and stick to a plan than
running like a hare in all directions. Reviews (of both the plan &
the portfolio ) are to be done regularly, to make any changes in the
allocations.
High returns are wrongly seen as what helps one achieve goals. Also, it
helps to understand that in a diversified portfolio, all components
would not be doing well, always. But, a properly constructed portfolio
would have various components and they need to be kept intact. Worrying
about some component that is not performing is another common fallacy.
What should be seen is whether the portfolio as such is performing well.
Disciplined investments & sticking to the suggested allocation /
portfolio is what actually helps achieve one’s goals.
We need to wean ourselves away from our near obsession with returns – in
our best interests. Kitna deti hai fixation can be very costly indeed!
There was one hilarious commercial some time back from an automobile
company which played on the Indian psyche of putting overwhelming
emphasis on the mileage over everything else. “Kitna deti hai?”, was
the question that the curious onlooker had asked of an incredulous
protagonist – one was explaining about Rockets, another a luxury Yatch
& yet another about a new generation battle tank!
But, I was not surprised; for I face the same questions from those I
deal with.
Focus on the basics : What are we trying to achieve in life? Are we
trying to get maximum returns to the exclusion of everything else? If
so, will it solve all the problems?
Most people focus on returns and chase products that offer the best
returns at any point. There is indeed an insistent belief that high
returns are something that we need to constantly strive for, to get
ahead in life. Hence, we tend to pick up the products which are “hot”
or trending, at any given point.
The predominant majority get it wrong as they join the bandwagon pretty
late – whether it is a stock market rally or a gold / real estate surge.
In doing so, they typically tend to get in when the rally is well
underway. In such a situation, they tend to purchase at inflated prices
which will cap their upsides or worse still, set them up for potential
downsides when the rally blows over.
Let me take an example. Suppose, Ramesh has bought real estate in 2012
when the markets were doing reasonably well. However, the markets have
turned turtle and are offering low to negative returns since. If Ramesh
has bought property, just to ride the wave, a lot of things would have
gone horribly wrong.
Firstly, the objective of fantastic return has not been met. Secondly,
Ramesh has taken some loans which he is servicing and paying a high
interest for an asset, which is not appreciating. He has not
considered any other parameter while investing – like liquidity,
concentration risk, risk inherent in this asset, tenure, returns etc.
This has been a blind investment into what is essentially an illiquid
product. Ramesh wants to sell & exit – but cannot, as there are no
buyers! He is now badly stuck. Many would be able to identify with
this.
People get into such transactions based on early successes. They tend to
feel invincible, if the first few transactions go well. Bets go up
steadily with each transaction – which is where the problem is.
Eventually when the cycle turns, they are left holding their lemons. A
string of successes in the beginning is, however, a wrong teacher!
People advertise their successes while quietly burying their failures in
investment. When some talk passionately about their successes, there
are many who get taken in – and the cycle of people trooping in to feed a
frenzy, gets underway.
While moving from product to product chasing returns, we fail to
consider important parameters which are equally important – like
liquidity, risk-reward, suitability, tenure etc. Such dalliances hardly
help in progressing towards smooth achievement of the goals.
Focus on goals : What is important in life is to achieve the
significant goals one may have. In fact, achieving our goals in the
time frames that we want is what is of paramount importance.
The typical high priority goals are – retirement, children’s education,
acquiring a home etc. Each goal will have a certain time horizon.
Investments will have to be done so that we may be able to meet the
goals. Hence, the investment should be such that it is consistent with
the need to achieve the goal.
For instance, if Ramesh wants to plan for child’s education, it might be
a decade away. For this goal, his investments can be in comparatively
aggressive assets like equities. In this case, near term liquidity is
not a concern area, tenure of the investment can be long & regular
income is not necessary.
Once we decide on the instrument which has the potential for good
returns, we can stay invested and not liquidate it to chase the next
rainbow which appears on the horizon. Many of the assets have their
cycles & those who stay invested for long, get to weather the cycles
better; also, with longer tenure, the inherent risk reduces & the
return potential improves. Market timing becomes less and less
important, if the tenure is long.
Strategic & Tactical asset allocation : Normally, client’s assets
are allocated based on their goals, how long the client has till
retirement, their risk tolerance levels & other considerations like
liquidity, risk-reward of the asset, requirement of regular returns
& their frequency etc.
Once the assets have been allocated as per such considerations, it
should be allowed to work. For that, the assets should be allowed to
remain invested for long to show desired results. That is the strategic
asset allocation.
Based on the movements in the markets & based on opportunistic
considerations, one may want to bring in some new assets which are doing
well then & make certain changes to the portfolio. But these
changes should be such that they tinker around the edges & not
change the core allocation. This is a tactical asset allocation to
potentially take advantage of the unfolding opportunities. A change in
the portfolio constitution of 10-15% can be fine when it comes to
tactical allocation. If it goes beyond that, it will change the
strategic asset allocation that has been suggested, which is not
desirable.
In summary : Goal achievement is what is really important. Hence, it
is important to keep the focus on the life goals, more than what
investment returns one gets at any point. One should invest in a
disciplined manner following the strategic asset allocation suggestions,
which is what ensures goal achievement. It is not necessary to get all
excited about assets which are doing well at some intermediate point;
it’s more important to stay focused on the goal and stick to a plan than
running like a hare in all directions. Reviews (of both the plan &
the portfolio ) are to be done regularly, to make any changes in the
allocations.
High returns are wrongly seen as what helps one achieve goals. Also, it
helps to understand that in a diversified portfolio, all components
would not be doing well, always. But, a properly constructed portfolio
would have various components and they need to be kept intact. Worrying
about some component that is not performing is another common fallacy.
What should be seen is whether the portfolio as such is performing well.
Disciplined investments & sticking to the suggested allocation /
portfolio is what actually helps achieve one’s goals.
We need to wean ourselves away from our near obsession with returns – in
our best interests. Kitna deti hai fixation can be very costly indeed!